I have never been comfortable with the concept of clubs.
In school, I never joined the chess club, or the math club, or any sort of club for that matter. Clubs were for those who couldn’t make friends on their own. People who needed to constantly surround themselves with other people to feel validated as people.
Secret societies seemed even worse, the idea of initiation and ritual and adherence to arcane doctrines smacking of unnecessary conspiracy. If you want to be in a club, why not own it?
I would never be a member of any club that would accept someone like me as a member, the old saying goes. It’s often attributed to Groucho Marx, but Woody Allen stole it, and meant it. Now, there’s a club I wouldn’t want to join.
However, my most preferred type of sandwich has to be the club sandwich. In most restaurants, you don’t even have to show a membership card to order one.
A triple-decker, the basic club sandwich consists of sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on three slices of toasted white bread, cut into quarters, toothpicks skewering the wedges in place. Some restaurants ham it up with ham and cheddar cheese, which is fine, but in my opinion excessive.
There is already such thing as a ham and cheese sandwich, which is perfectly complete on its own. I find that bacon plus ham is too much pork to put together on one plate. A good sandwich should only be constructed of a few constituent ingredients. And the beauty of the classic club is its simplicity. Less is more.
I have long searched Montreal for the best club sandwich, and a few old-school diners stand out. There’s Oxford Café on Sherbrooke in NDG. They’ve been around since 1944. Oxford makes their club sandwiches with real chicken, not prepackaged pressed turkey, so they score points for authenticity. A great club sandwich is worth travelling for. But unless you’re already in NDG, it’s a bit of a journey.
I also like Paul’s Patates in Pointe-Saint-Charles. They’ve been open since the mid-1950s and, depending on who’s working, you may receive your club sandwich in geometrically sliced segments that would impress Pythagoras. Paul’s has a distinctive neighbourhood joint vibe, with the stainless steel countertops and the (sadly non-functional) jukeboxes, which are nonetheless time capsules of Quebec popular music.
Another plus is their homemade Bertrand spruce beer. It smells kind of funky, but the original recipe is not too sweet, not too carbonated, and hasn’t changed much in over a century.
I highly recommend both these diners and the club sandwiches therein. But recently, I’ve been returning to Chez Nick in Westmount and ordering the club sandwich, fries, a side of gravy, and a ginger ale. The combination of that particular lunch in that particular place is perhaps my favourite thing in life right now. Chez Nick has been going strong for 103 years, and there is an unmistakable air of history there that is hard to ignore.
Nick’s is by far the most elegant of these diners, being on Greene Avenue, where bourgeois retirees congregate, and young upwardly socially mobile families bring their prep school kids. But there’s a down-to-earth atmosphere, too, that makes anyone feel immediately comfortable and welcome, no matter how fancy or how casual you might look.
Nick’s is already famous to most Montrealers. The author Louise Penny has written about it in her Chief Inspector Armand Gamache mystery series, and frequently goes there herself for breakfasts when she’s in town. Other renowned writers have been regulars there, but I won’t name any names. Brian Mulroney used to stop in from time to time, and one of the staff recently told me that he once served Jean Chrétien.
Whenever I go to Chez Nick I feel like I’m part of this cast of illustrious and everyday characters. I’ve been visiting Nick’s for nearly 20 years, and it is the one restaurant in which I have never had a bad meal. I particularly love their club sandwiches which I customarily order dry, with a white paper container of mayo. That way, I can regulate the dressing in every bite.
There are lots of things that make Nick’s one of my favourite places in the city. The warm and long-time staff; the regulars, whom I’ve come to recognize and in some cases befriend; the ambiance; the legacy; the mythology. And of course, the club sandwich. But one thing I especially love about Nick’s is their gravy.
As a kid, it was a treat to go after school for a pre-dinner snack of French fries and gravy. My mom would habitually pick me up from class and take me to the local food court where we would order a basket of crinkle-cut fries and dip them in a tub of warm and salty brown sauce.
It was less routine that my dad would collect me, but I could usually convince him, too, to take me out for French fried potatoes. It was during one of these outings that I remember he gave me the news that he and my mom were divorcing. Certain things stick in your memory more than others, and that afternoon has embedded itself deeply into my experiential scrapbook.
I don’t recall it being particularly painful at the time, as one might expect of hearing such momentous news. Not to my 11-year-old self. It’s possible that the gravy and fries cushioned the blow. There’s a reason why we call some dishes “comfort food.” Disentangling sustenance from remembrance is an impossible task.
In my youth, I couldn’t wait to distance myself from my broken family. But I crave familiarity now, as the world appears to be coming apart at the seams.
Family comes in all different forms. It’s not just about genealogy. Long ago, my biological family was scattered to the wind. But I feel a sense of belonging at Nick’s, like I’ve found a club I want to be in.◼︎


You must be logged in to post a comment.